Journal of African Development

Introduction

Masculinities and gender norms in African societies are shaped by complex historical, cultural, social, and economic factors. The construction of masculinity—and the set of expectations, behaviors, and roles assigned to men—has far-reaching consequences not just for men, but also for women, children, and broader community dynamics. Contemporary Africa is witnessing a fluid negotiation between traditional gender roles, legacies of colonialism, economic transformation, and global discourses on gender equality. This article explores these themes extensively, drawing on current research, regional variations, cases, and future possibilities.

Understanding Masculinities in Africa

Beyond Biological Essentialism

African masculinities are not static or monolithic. Rather, they are historically constructed identities, shaped by local customs, mythologies, social institutions, and, in many cases, colonial legacies. Traditionally, masculinity was less about rigid behavioral codes and more about fulfilling roles within kinship, spirituality, and communal responsibility^[1][2].

Multiple and Fluid Masculinities

Recent scholarship emphasizes the diversity and contestation among different forms of masculinity—hegemonic, subordinate, and subversive—across regions and age groups. Both men and women have enacted masculine roles in various historical and contemporary contexts, challenging strict binaries. Indigenous African communities often integrated fluid gender systems, allowing individuals of different biological sexes to occupy masculine or feminine roles based on social needs and contexts, rather than biology alone^[1][3][4].

Traditional Masculine Ideals and Gender Relations

Roles and Social Expectations

Common elements of traditional African masculinity include:

• Provider and protector: Men are expected to ensure the material welfare and security of their families.
• Authority and decision-making: Patriarchal structures positioned men as household heads and community leaders.
• Rites of passage: Communal rituals, such as circumcision (ulwaluko among Xhosa), mark the transition to manhood, imparting responsibilities to maintain community morals and cohesion^[5][6].

Gender Hierarchies

Traditionally, these ideals buttressed systems that prioritized male authority over women and children, codifying property rights, marriage, and social mobility along gendered lines. Practices such as bride price (lobola), polygamy, and inheritance laws reinforced gendered power^[6].

Impacts of Colonialism and Modernity

The imposition of Western masculinity norms during colonialism disrupted traditional gender systems. African men were excluded from economic and political power under colonial regimes, yet simultaneously expected to maintain patriarchal authority in their communities^[2]. Socioeconomic changes—urbanization, shifting labor markets, and exposure to new cultural influences—continue to contest and reshape masculine identities^[7][8][9].

Table 1: Key Domains Influencing Masculinities

Contemporary Challenges and Shifting Gender Norms

Gender Norms in Transformation

Expanding access to education, women's empowerment, legal reform, and youth activism are challenging rigid gender roles. In some households, men take on caregiving roles or share domestic duties, particularly in urban contexts and among younger generations. However, traditional expectations persist, often justified by religious or cultural narratives^[10][11].

Health, Violence, and Social Harm

Strict masculinities can fuel social harm, such as gender-based violence, risky behaviors, and resistance to seeking healthcare. Across the continent, men experience pressure to eschew emotional vulnerability—a factor linked to mental health struggles and participation in violence^[12][13][11]. Campaigns and policies increasingly target the reduction of gender-based violence by questioning harmful masculine norms.

Figure 1: Attitudes Toward Gender Equality Among African Men

Percentages represent approximate regional averages from IMAGES survey (2023)^[12].

New Models: Progressive and Relational Masculinities

Progressive masculinities are emerging in response to social movements, policy changes, and economic realities. Traits increasingly valued include:

• Responsible parenting and engaged fatherhood
• Advocacy for nonviolence and equitable relationships
• Emotional literacy and openness
• Standing against gender-based violence

Such models challenge the association of masculinity with dominance, aggression, and emotional stoicism^[14][7][10].

Barriers and Resistance

Many men face economic marginalization and social stress, exacerbating feelings of 'crisis' surrounding masculinity. Factors such as unemployment, rural-urban migration, and changing family structures can foster resentment or backlash against women’s progress. Intergenerational, rural-urban, and cultural divides characterize the negotiation of gender roles, often producing tensions within families and communities^[7][8][10].

Intersectionality and Alternative Masculinities

Scholars and activists highlight the importance of intersectionality in understanding African masculinities: the interplay of gender with class, ethnicity, age, sexual orientation, and disability. Queer African masculinities particularly challenge the myth of a single, fixed masculine identity and demonstrate the resilience and diversity of gender expressions in Africa^[3].

Policy and Social Responses

Community-Based Interventions

• Gender-transformative programs: NGOs and governments employ workshops, mentorship, and education to foster equitable masculinities and challenge violence^[12][7].
• Reform of initiation rites: Some communities have revised rites of passage to teach gender respect and consent.

Legal and Institutional Change

Policies promoting gender mainstreaming, parental leave, and anti-discrimination are advancing, though enforcement and social acceptance vary. Engaging men as allies in gender equality, rather than as obstacles, is an increasing focus.

Table 2: Examples of Masculinity Interventions in Africa

Conclusion

African masculinities are dynamic, complex, and continually negotiated. Gender norms in society are deeply rooted but not immutable. While some norms perpetuate inequality and harm, others support community, responsibility, and care. Understanding and supporting the ongoing evolution of masculinities is critical to realizing gender equity, improving health and social outcomes, and enriching the lives of all Africans.

References (MLA Style, as required above the title)

1. Oxford Research Encyclopedias. "African Masculinities." 2019.
2. Lwando Scott. "African Masculinities." Centre for Humanities Research, University of the Western Cape.
3. "Traditional African Masculine Ideals and Gender Roles." IJRAMT, 2024.
4. Men and Gender Equality in Africa. Equimundo, 2025.
5. Harrison, A. "Gender Role and Relationship Norms among Young South African Men and Women." PMC, 2006.
6. Khosa-Nkatini, H.P. "Gender role changes in African households." SciELO, 2023.
7. "Creating the new man in Africa." Pambazuka, 2017.
8. Ammann, C. "Masculinities in Africa beyond crisis: complexity, fluidity." Taylor & Francis, 2021.
9. Kritikos, Alexander S. "Evolving Gender Norms in Contemporary Africa." AJPPA, 2024.
10. "Becoming Men: Performing responsible masculinities in urban Africa." CORDIS H2020.
11. Mfecane, S. "Ending gender-based violence: An Africanist approach." LSE, 2019.
12. Khosa-Nkatini, H.P. "Gender role changes in African households: Theology and psychology perspectives." SciELO, 2024.
13. "Changing Masculinities and Moral Becoming in an African Urban Context." JSTOR, 2004.
14. Scott, L. "African Masculinities: Queerness and Tradition." UCT, 2021.
15. "Evolving Gender Norms in Contemporary Africa." AJPPA, 2024.
16. "Of Masks and Masculinities in Africa." Sage Journals, 2023.
17. "How Gender Norms and Expectations Shape South African Masculinity." Sage Journals, 2024.
18. "Gender roles in African culture and its impact on agriculture." Farrelly Mitchell, 2025.
19. "African Masculinity in Question." Georgetown Journal of International Affairs, 2024.
20. Owens, B. "African Masculinity in Question." GJIA, 2024.

⁂